Classification of scientific approaches to the study of autonomous entities in the state
Abstract
The article presents the key approaches and points of view of scien tists of the XX-XXI centuries on the nature and essential features of au tonomies. Based on the comparative analysis, the author has carried out the typologization of the researchers ‘ points of view into four main groups. The issues of criteria for assigning territorial units to autonomous entities are also touched upon. A comparative analysis of the scientific positions of foreign and domestic scientists in the field of political research on the pecu liarities of the emergence and trajectory of the evolution of autonomies in the territorial-political system of states is carried out. The key and actual features of modern autonomous entities as part of both unitary and federal states are identified.
About the Author
E. E. Kochetkov
Russian University of Transport
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Kochetkov Egor Evgenievich, Candidate of Political Sciences, Associate Professor, Associate Professor
Moscow
References
1. Avakian S.A. Constitutional law: Encyclopedic dictionary [Konsti tucionnoe pravo: Enciklopedicheskij slovar’] / S. A. Avakian, K. F. Gutsenko, A. I. Kovler, et al.; Ed. S. A. Avakian. - M.: NORM (Publishing group NORM - INFRA-M), 2000. p. 6.
2. Damirov Javid Yagub ogly. Problems of the development of federal relations in the “composite” subjects of Russia [Problemy razvitiya feder ativnyh otnoshenij v «slozhnosostavnyh» sub”ektah Rossii]: autoref. diss. cand. jurid. Sciences. M., 2003. p. 20.
3. Irinin A.E. The essence of the unitary form of government [Sushch nost’ unitarnoj formy gosudarstvennogo ustrojstva]: abstract. diss... cand. jurid. sciences’. Krasnodar, 2007.
4. Lukasheva N.V. The legal status of autonomous entities in the coun tries of Northern Europe [Pravovoe polozhenie avtonomnyh obrazovanij v stranah Severnoj Evropy]. Diss...cand. jurid. sciences’. Yekaterinburg, 1998. p. 165.
5. Mishin A. A. Constitutional (state) law of foreign countries [Konsti tucionnoe (gosudarstvennoe) pravo zarubezhnyh stran][Text]: textbook for universities / A. A. Mishin; Interdisciplinary Center of Philosophy of Law. - 17th ed., ispr. and add. - Moscow : Statute, 2013. p.111.
6. Narutto S.V. Territory in public law [Territoriya v publichnom prave]. p. 269.
7. Novozhilov A.M. Spatial resource in modernization processes [Pros transtvennyj resurs v processah modernizacii //Putevoditel’ predprinimatel ya] // Entrepreneur’s Guide. 2020. Vol. 13. No. 3. pp. 172-180.
8. Fedyakin A.V. Basic approaches to spatial differentiation in the re gional policy of modern Russia [Osnovnye podhody k prostranstvennoj dif ferenciacii v regional’noj politike sovremennoj Rossii] // Bulletin of the Rus sian Nation. 2019. No. 5 (69). pp. 9-39.
Review
For citations:
Kochetkov E.E. Classification of scientific approaches to the study of autonomous entities in the state. P.O.I.S.K. 2021;(6):19-28. (In Russ.)
Views:
18
Email this article 